Automatic or Quartz Watch? How to Choose the Right One

Updated

Buy quartz if you want the most accurate, lowest-maintenance watch for the money. Buy an automatic if you want a self-winding watch with character that can last for decades with servicing. Both are good choices, and the right one depends on how you wear a watch.

The two types look the same from across a room. The difference is what happens inside the case, and that shapes accuracy, running costs and how the watch feels to own.

How each one keeps time

A quartz watch runs on a battery. The battery sends a current through a tiny quartz crystal, which vibrates 32,768 times a second. A circuit counts those vibrations and drives a small motor that moves the hands, usually one tick per second.

An automatic watch has no battery. A coiled mainspring stores energy, and a gear train releases it through a balance wheel that swings back and forth at a steady rate. A weighted rotor turns as you move your arm and winds the mainspring for you.

Seiko released the first quartz wristwatch, the Quartz Astron, on Christmas Day 1969. Quartz went on to transform the watch industry. Mechanical watches never went away, though. People kept buying them for the engineering and the feel, not the convenience.

Accuracy

Quartz wins clearly. Seiko quotes an accuracy of plus or minus 15 seconds a month for its standard quartz watches. That works out at about half a second a day.

A good automatic usually gains or loses a few seconds a day. Swiss chronometer certification, run by COSC, asks for an average daily rate between minus 4 and plus 6 seconds. A mechanical watch also varies with position, temperature and how fully wound it is.

Strong magnets can also make a mechanical watch run fast. Our guide to checking and fixing a magnetised watch shows what to do if that happens.

In practice, a few seconds a day means a quick check against your phone every week or so. Many owners enjoy that small ritual. If you need split-second timing every day without thinking about it, quartz is the logical choice.

Batteries, power and servicing

Quartz watches need a new battery every few years. Seiko puts battery life at two to four years, depending on the movement and the battery fitted. If you swim with the watch, have the seals checked when the battery is changed.

An automatic never needs a battery. Wear it and it keeps running. Take it off and it runs until the mainspring unwinds, then stops. A KOMPAS, with its Miyota 9039 automatic (Citizen group), keeps going for about 42 hours off the wrist. A few turns of the crown bring it back to life.

When an automatic stops, nothing is lost. Wind it, set the time and it carries on.

Automatics do need servicing. Oils age and parts wear, so every several years a watchmaker cleans, lubricates and regulates the movement. Intervals vary by brand and by how hard the watch is worn. Our guide to automatic watch care and servicing covers what to expect.

Cheap quartz movements are often swapped out rather than repaired. A well-made automatic is built to be opened, cleaned and kept running. With care, it can outlast its first owner.

How they feel on the wrist

This is where the two types part ways. A quartz seconds hand jumps once a second. An automatic seconds hand moves in small steps that look like a smooth sweep.

At 28,800 vibrations per hour, the Miyota 9039 moves its seconds hand in eight small steps every second. Our beat rate explainer shows why a higher rate looks smoother.

An automatic is also something you can watch working. Through an exhibition caseback you can see the balance wheel swing and the rotor turn as you move. For many people, that is the whole point.

Sound is part of it too. Hold an automatic to your ear and you hear a fast, soft ticking from the balance.

Automatics are often a little thicker and heavier, because the movement has more parts. The gap has narrowed. A KOMPAS is 10.4 mm thick, which sits comfortably under a shirt cuff.

Setting is slightly different too. Many automatics, including the Miyota 9039, have hacking seconds. Pull the crown and the seconds hand stops, so you can set the watch to the exact second. Our note on hacking seconds explains how.

Price and value

Quartz gives you more watch for less money. Quartz movements cost less to produce, so a quartz watch is usually cheaper than a similar automatic.

An automatic movement has many more parts and needs more skilled assembly. You pay for that engineering up front and for servicing later. In return you get a watch that holds your interest and can be handed on.

Running costs differ as well. A quartz watch costs little more than a battery every few years. An automatic costs nothing day to day, but an occasional service is a bigger single bill.

Between the two sit dependable automatic workhorses. Movements such as the Miyota 9039 keep a well-finished mechanical watch within reach. That is why many independent brands build around them, and KOMPAS is one of them.

Other options worth knowing

A hand-wound mechanical watch works like an automatic but has no rotor. You wind it by the crown, usually once a day. Many people enjoy that daily contact with the watch.

Solar quartz watches charge a rechargeable cell from light, so they rarely need a battery change. The cell still ages eventually, and a watchmaker can replace it.

Many automatics, the Miyota 9039 included, can also be wound by hand. That is useful when the watch has stopped after a few days in a drawer.

Which one suits you

  • Choose quartz if you want grab-and-go accuracy and the lowest running costs.
  • Choose quartz for a watch you leave in a drawer for weeks. It will still show the right time when you pick it up.
  • Choose quartz if you rotate between many watches and do not want to reset them each time.
  • Choose an automatic if you enjoy mechanical things and like the idea of a watch with no battery.
  • Choose an automatic if you plan to wear one watch most days and keep it for many years.
  • Choose an automatic if you value the smooth sweep, the visible movement and the small ritual of setting it.

For an everyday field watch, an automatic makes a lot of sense. It needs no battery on a long trip, and simply wearing it keeps it wound. Our East, in forest green, is a good example of the type.

There is no wrong answer here. Many collectors own both, with a quartz for grab-and-go days and an automatic for the rest.

Frequently asked questions

Is an automatic watch more accurate than quartz?

No. A standard quartz watch is accurate to around 15 seconds a month, while a good automatic gains or loses a few seconds a day.

Do automatic watches need batteries?

No. An automatic runs on a mainspring that a rotor winds as you move. If it stops, wind it by hand or simply wear it.

How long does a quartz watch battery last?

Usually a few years. Seiko quotes two to four years for its quartz watches, depending on the movement and the battery fitted.

Why do automatic watches cost more?

They contain far more moving parts and need more skilled assembly. They also need servicing every several years to keep running well.

What happens if I do not wear my automatic watch?

It runs until the mainspring unwinds and then stops. The Miyota 9039 runs for about 42 hours off the wrist. Wind and set it before you wear it again.

All four KOMPAS models share the same Miyota 9039 automatic. See the KOMPAS range.

Previous
Previous

What Is Hacking Seconds and Why Does It Matter?

Next
Next

A Short History of British Military Watches, from the W.W.W. to the G10