Updated · By Adventure Man
A smartwatch does far more on a hike. GPS tracking, maps on some models, heart rate and safety features, but it needs charging every day or two to every couple of weeks. A mechanical watch only tells the time, but it never needs a charger and can keep going for decades, which is why many walkers and travellers end up wearing both.
We make a mechanical field watch, so you know where our heart is. But this is meant to be fair, and on several counts the smartwatch simply wins.
Battery and charging
This is the big one. Every smartwatch runs on a battery, and how long it lasts depends heavily on the model and on how hard you use GPS and the screen.
At the time of writing, Apple quotes up to 24 hours of normal use for the Apple Watch Series 12, and up to 10 hours of workout tracking. The Apple Watch Ultra 4 is quoted at up to 50 hours of normal use, up to 84 hours in Low Power Mode and up to 18 hours of workout tracking. Garmin's outdoor watches go much further – its manual quotes the fēnix 8 AMOLED 47 mm at up to 16 days in smartwatch mode and up to 47 hours of GPS-only tracking, both with the display set to wake on a wrist gesture.
On a day walk, none of that matters much. On a multi-day trek, it means a cable, a power bank and a plan.
An automatic mechanical watch winds itself as you move. The Miyota 9039 inside a KOMPAS holds about 42 hours of power reserve when fully wound, so if you take it off at night it will still be running in the morning. Leave it in a drawer for a couple of days and it stops. A few turns of the crown and setting the time gets it going again. There is nothing to plug in, ever. Our guide on how to wind and set an automatic watch covers the details.
GPS and navigation
The smartwatch wins outright. It can record your route, show your position, guide you back to the start and, on some models, display a map. For many hikers that is the main reason to own one.
A mechanical watch has no idea where you are. The best it can do is the sun method for a rough direction (see how to use a watch as a compass), and that really is rough.
Neither replaces a paper map and compass – batteries run flat, and the sun goes behind cloud.
Heart rate and health data
Again, the smartwatch. Optical heart-rate sensors on the wrist give you a running record of effort, sleep and recovery, and on the right models they feed straight into training plans. Wrist sensors are better at trends than at exact second-by-second readings, but for most walkers that is all they need.
A mechanical watch gives you a seconds hand – count your pulse for 15 seconds and multiply by four.
Safety features
Many smartwatches can share your location, call for help or detect a fall, depending on the model and on whether they have a phone or mobile signal to work with. A mechanical watch offers none of this, and on solo walks that can matter.
Durability and the long view
Both can be tough. Outdoor smartwatches are built for knocks, and many have sapphire or hardened glass. A good mechanical watch is a steel case, a sapphire crystal and a movement that can be serviced for decades.
The difference is what happens over the years. A smartwatch battery slowly loses capacity, and the software eventually stops being updated, so most people replace one every few years. A mechanical watch does not go out of date, but it needs a service every several years, and a hard knock or a strong magnet can upset its timekeeping. Neither is indestructible.
Legibility in bright sun and at night
Modern smartwatch screens are bright, and some outdoor models use displays that read best in direct sun. But an always-on screen costs battery, and some displays dim or sleep until you lift your wrist.
A mechanical watch is always on. High-contrast hands and markers, plus a sapphire crystal with anti-reflective coating on both sides, make it readable at a glance in full sun. At night, Swiss Super-LumiNova glows after charging in daylight, with no button to press, although it fades gradually through the night. More in Super-LumiNova explained.
Cold
Lithium batteries lose capacity in the cold, so a smartwatch left exposed on a winter ridge can drain faster than you expect, and touchscreens are awkward with gloves on. Physical buttons help.
A mechanical watch keeps running in the cold, but extreme temperatures can nudge its rate. Makers quote accuracy for normal conditions. Seiko, for example, specifies the accuracy of its 4R35 movement for wear at 5 to 35 °C. Worn under a sleeve, both types stay close to body temperature and behave themselves.
Water
Rain is no problem for either. For swimming, check the rating – many smartwatches are fine for the pool or open water, and a KOMPAS is rated to 100 m, which covers swimming and snorkelling. With a mechanical watch, do not pull out or turn the crown when it is wet. Our guide to what 100 m water resistance really means goes into more depth.
Weight and comfort
This depends on the model more than the type. Big outdoor smartwatches can be chunky on a slim wrist. A 39 mm mechanical watch on a rubber or nylon strap is easy to forget about, and quick-release pins make strap swaps take seconds.
Cost over the years
A smartwatch is often cheaper up front, but most people replace one every few years. A mechanical watch costs more on day one, plus an occasional service, then keeps going. Over a decade or two the sums can be closer than they look, depending on how often you upgrade.
Distraction
Notifications on the wrist are useful in a city and less welcome on a summit. You can switch them off, but some people find a mechanical watch is the easiest way to leave the phone in the bag and just walk.
Side by side
| What matters | Smartwatch | Mechanical watch |
|---|---|---|
| Power | Needs charging, from daily to every couple of weeks depending on model and use | Winds itself as you move. No charger |
| Navigation | GPS track, back-to-start, maps on some models | None (rough sun-compass trick only) |
| Heart rate and health | Continuous tracking | Count your own pulse |
| Safety features | Location sharing, calling for help, fall detection on some models | None |
| Legibility | Bright screens. Always-on costs battery | Always on. Lume at night |
| Cold | Battery drains faster. Touchscreen awkward with gloves | Keeps running. Rate can shift in extreme cold |
| Water | Check the rating | Check the rating. KOMPAS is 100 m |
| Long-term | Battery ages. Software support ends | Serviceable for decades |
| Distraction | Notifications, unless switched off | None |
Battery figures are the makers' own claims, checked on 19 November 2026 on Apple's UK battery page and in Garmin's fēnix 8 series manual. Real-world results vary with settings and use.
Why many people wear both
For a lot of people the answer is not one or the other. A smartwatch handles training runs, gym sessions and route recording. A mechanical watch comes out for trips, weekends and everything that is not about data.
On a long trek, some walkers keep the smartwatch in a pocket for recording the route and wear the mechanical watch for the time. When travelling, it is one fewer thing to charge in a hotel room with the wrong plug.
Which should you choose?
- Choose a smartwatch if you want GPS tracking, heart-rate data or safety features, and you are happy to charge it.
- Choose a mechanical watch if you want something that just works, needs no charger, lasts for decades and keeps you off your phone.
- Choose both if you train with data but travel light on screens.
If the mechanical side appeals, a field watch is the natural fit for walking and travel – legible, tough and simple. The KOMPAS North is a 39 mm automatic with 100 m water resistance, a sapphire crystal, and both a rubber and a nylon strap in the box.
Frequently asked questions
Is a mechanical watch good for hiking?
Yes, for telling the time. A field watch with a clear dial, sapphire crystal and good water resistance copes well with walking and rough weather. It will not track your route or heart rate, so pair it with a map, a compass or a GPS device.
Will an automatic watch stop if I do not wear it?
Yes, once its power reserve runs out. A KOMPAS holds about 42 hours when fully wound. If it stops, wind the crown a few turns, set the time and it will carry on.
Do smartwatches work in the cold?
Yes, but batteries drain faster in the cold and touchscreens are awkward with gloves. Wearing the watch under a sleeve keeps it warmer and helps the battery last.
Can I swim with a mechanical watch?
If it is rated for it. A KOMPAS is rated to 100 m, which covers swimming and snorkelling. Do not pull out or turn the crown while the watch is wet.
One fewer thing to charge – see the KOMPAS North or browse all four colours.